When you’re told “you suck” … with a smile

by Jon Plotner

man standing in front of group of men

Working in the customer service industry is one of the most challenging and most rewarding experiences. While I’ve had a lot of different roles throughout my career — from education to pastoral ministry to software and technology — they’ve all had this thread of customer service. I have always had jobs where my role was to serve others in some fashion. And part of serving others is making sure that there is some level of satisfaction.

It all started about 31 years ago when I got my first “real job” after graduating from college with my bachelor’s degree in education. Within a matter of a few weeks, as a 23-year-old naive Midwestern farm boy, I had my first round of parent teacher conferences. Quickly, I came face to face with the reality that some people (aka parents) didn’t appreciate the work that I was doing. And somehow, the poor grade “I had given their child” was somehow due to a failure on my part — never the result of poor discipline on their child’s part. Welcome to adulthood. Welcome to People 101. Welcome to Customer Service.

Fast forward a few years when very similar scenarios played out in my pastoral role in the church. As a worship pastor, the music was too loud, not loud enough. Too fast, too slow. Too short, too long. Too new, too old. You get the idea.

People 201 was just as difficult as 101 was. The only difference was that these people’s criticism was now cloaked in the name of Jesus, The Gospel, Kindgom Work, and all those other words that good Christians like to throw around to make you feel bad. Or better yet, get you to change to see it their way.

As of about 8 months ago, I’m back working for a SaaS company (software as a service) in the faith-based market, so I get to see all of these world collide as I lead an implementation team in what we’re now calling Customer Success. Over the last 31 years, in all of these roles, I’ve learned that people are pretty much the same. The only difference is I now have enough stories accumulated that I could write a book … or two … probably more like three or four.

Which brings me to today. This week I had a conversation with one of the customers that I’ve been working with over the last few months. They’ve experienced a lot of things in those few short months including the loss of their key leader that kicked off the project with me, the closing of one of their campuses, and now a few new staff members that have a lot of new and fresh ideas that they suddenly feel will suddenly make everything better. In the midst of all of this, they’re transitioning to an entirely new giving and engagement platform that I’m helping them implement. Painless, right?

As we were chatting on the phone this week, this woman apologized for all the grief they’ve caused, the challenges they’ve presented, and the back and forth difficulties we’ve had working together. They’ve pushed hard against a few of the things that I’ve asked them to do. They didn’t like all of them. Some of them were painful. They spent some time kicking and screaming. And kicking some more. This week, she apologized for that.

The apology wasn’t necessary. Difficult conversations and painful transitions are part of projects like this. And it’s my job to navigate this with our customers while not taking it personally. Even in the midst of all of this, I realized that I truly loved working with them … alongside them. And it is because of one simple thing. Kindness.

It’s through times like these that I’ve been able to learn some very valuable. In all of my various roles, I’ve been able to work through a lot of difficult situations. And some of those were really hard, challenging, and self defeating. Others of them were equally as hard; but, in the end, ended up being life-giving and productive. And there was one key difference between the two. Some people are kind. And some people are not.

I can work through the emotions and difficulties of hard and challenging situations. When people are kind. You can be brutally honest and tell me hard things. You can tell me where my company or my church or my school have missed the target … even if it may not be entirely true … or completely true.

But if you are kind, I can receive it. Not only can I receive it … but also, I can learn from it. And grow … and become better. Even if it’s hard. Even when I may not be able to change those things. But kindness, makes it possible.

The reality is we live in a world where people no longer know how to be kind. In the name of truth, honesty, fairness … whatever it is, we believe that we can be mean and that’s ok. Meanness is never ok. We must learn to be kinder people. One of my favorite quotes from Brene Brown is, “Clear is kind.”

Kindness doesn’t translate into watered-down mediocrity. Kindness translates into honesty and integrity. Yet, it also means that we truly care about the individual on the other side of the message. And because of that, we communicate in a humane, caring way in order to maintain the dignity and respect of the other person.

People … we need to re-learn the discipline of kindness. If we will, the world will be a different place … a better place in which we can live and grow.

Written By Jon Plotner

Related Posts

green plants on soil

Two Types of Leaders: Which One Are You?

In all my years of coaching leaders — executives, pastors, ministry professionals, and marketplace leaders — I've noticed a pattern that never changes. It doesn't matter what industry you're in, what size your organization is, or how long you've been in leadership....

read more...
train, mountains, fields, rice fields, rice plantation, rice farm, rice paddies, railway, railroad, railway system, passenger train, transport, rural, countryside, landscape, nature

The System vs. Your Soul: How Senior Leaders Reframe Criticism

High-capacity, high-care leaders often risk tying their identity too closely to outcomes and other people’s reactions. When ownership increases, so does emotional exposure, causing feedback to land on your identity instead of just your role. This post shares a framework to build durable internal boundaries, allowing you to keep listening deeply without absorbing criticism as a personal verdict. The core practice is a crucial mental reframe: treating feedback as shared insight about the system we’re all in, not a critique of your worth. Learn how to set internal boundary rules, use cognitive defusion to create distance from sharp thoughts, and implement a repeatable process for transforming tough conversations into raw material for shared learning.

read more...
The Eye of the Storm: Why the Best Leaders are Carriers of the Calm

The Eye of the Storm: Why the Best Leaders are Carriers of the Calm

In navigating the complexities of leadership, one must recognize that the true essence of influence lies not just in decision-making but in the energy we radiate; the most impactful leaders harness a thoughtful stillness that invites connection and collaboration, ensuring their teams feel supported rather than strained, inspiring a collective resilience that transcends mere survival and fosters an environment where creativity flourishes and potential is fully realized, highlighting that the ultimate goal of leadership is not to command but to cultivate an atmosphere where every voice can rise, contributing to a symphony of shared success.

read more...
multi cultural people

Support & Leadership: Fostering Ownership and Partnership for Results

Yesterday, I attended a customer meeting with one of our customer success managers, and it turned into a real eye-opener about what leadership should be. My colleague shared on LinkedIn that instead of needing more oversight, Individual Contributors just want ownership and support. When leaders show up, they’re not just a title; they create trust and momentum. It’s key for leaders to champion decisions and support their teams without judgment. Leaders should empower rather than evaluate. The goal is to fuse the roles of leaders and ICs, promoting shared ownership and respect, so everyone wins together. It’s all about partnership, not hierarchy.

read more...
Patience in Bloom: Why Waiting Matters

Patience in Bloom: Why Waiting Matters

The story of a pink rhododendron that took six years to bloom serves as a metaphor for personal growth. Despite consistent care, it initially showed no visible signs of progress. This spring, it burst into beautiful blossoms, prompting reflections on life’s invisible growth periods. Just as the rhododendron established its roots before blooming, we too can spend long periods working hard without immediate results. This emphasizes that patience and continued effort are essential, as many projects and goals develop quietly beneath the surface. The waiting time is not wasted, and eventually, each person’s ‘moment of blooming’ will arrive.

read more...
man wearing black polo shirt and gray pants sitting on white chair

Responding to Feedback: Strategies for Effective Growth

Feedback can feel personal and challenging, often seeming like a direct attack on one’s identity. However, understanding that feedback reflects behavior and perception, rather than core identity, is crucial. Acknowledging that others’ perceptions can differ from intentions allows an opportunity for growth. It’s essential to approach feedback with humility and clarity, asking questions to bridge misunderstandings. While not all feedback may be entirely valid, each piece can reveal insights about your influence and relationships. Ultimately, how you respond to feedback can transform it from a threat to a valuable tool for personal and professional development.

read more...

0 Comments