How to Lead with Calm in a World Full of Chaos

by Jon Plotner

man standing in front of group of men

In June of 2012, our family moved to Colorado Springs from the Midwest. It was only a few days after settling in when we witnessed something unforgettable. We were spending the day “touristing” on top of Pikes Peak when we noticed a small plume of smoke rising in the distance. Curious, I pointed it out to a nearby forest ranger. Without missing a beat, he looked at the smoke and said, “You better head down the mountain quickly; that small fire is about to be out of control.” As Midwesterners, we’d never experienced fires so we quickly heeded his advice.  

As we made our way down the mountain, what started as a small campfire quickly grew into a raging wildfire. The mountainside was soon engulfed in flames, with helicopters already circling overhead to try and control the blaze. Less than an hour later, roads were closed, and hundreds of homes were suddenly in danger. The end result is what is now referred to as the Waldo Canyon Fire which was one of the most destructive in Colorado history destroying 346 homes and burning over 18,000 acres.

Not nearly as dramatic as this story is how similar our emotions can be. Emotions spread like wildfire. Whether you realize it or not, your mood and energy rub off on your team. As a leader, that emotional ripple effect gets amplified, influencing not just individuals but your entire team’s culture. This is the concept of emotional contagion, and it’s more powerful than most leaders realize.

Emotional contagion is when your emotions transfer to others, almost like catching a cold. It happens instinctively through non-verbal cues—your facial expressions, tone of voice, and body language all send signals that people pick up on. If you’re not careful, your stress or frustration can spread just as fast as that wildfire, creating a tense and negative atmosphere. But just like how a fire can be controlled with the right response, emotional contagion can be managed. If you’re intentional, you can use your emotional influence to foster positivity, resilience, and collaboration instead of chaos.

I learned the importance of managing emotional contagion from a manager I work with. He introduced me to the concept of a non-anxious presence, something he picked up from one of his mentors. As I’ve thought about this over many months, it’s become clear to me that it is critical in leadership. Being a non-anxious presence doesn’t mean ignoring problems or staying detached—it’s about remaining calm and steady, even when everything feels out of control. When you can maintain that level-headedness, you become the anchor your team needs during difficult times, helping them stay grounded and focused.

The Emotional Domino Effect in Leadership

Emotional contagion happens fast and without us even realizing it. There’s science behind this, too—humans have something called mirror neurons, which make us mimic the emotions of others. If someone’s smiling, we tend to smile back. If they’re stressed or upset, we might start feeling on edge, too.

In a leadership role, this matters more than you think. When times get tough or things feel uncertain, your team looks to you for cues on how they should feel. If you’re panicking or frazzled, your team is going to pick up on that energy and reflect it. On the flip side, if you stay cool, calm, and collected, they’ll take that as a sign that they can keep their focus and keep pushing forward.

Picture this: your team is up against a tight deadline, and the pressure is on. If you start hovering over every detail or letting your stress show, your team will feed off that energy, making them more anxious and less productive. But if you can project calm confidence—letting them know you trust their abilities—you’ll notice a shift. The team will stay more focused, energized, and solution-oriented.

Why Leaders Need a Non-Anxious Presence

When you lead with a non-anxious presence, you unlock several important benefits:

  1. Better Decision-Making: Anxiety throws us into fight-or-flight mode, making it harder to think creatively or weigh options. A calm leader can think more clearly and guide their team toward smart, strategic decisions.
  1. Builds Trust: Trust is built on consistency. When you’re calm under pressure, your team feels safe and secure, knowing that you’ve got things under control. That trust will make them more likely to follow your lead, even in challenging situations.
  1. Creates a Positive Culture: Your emotional state sets the tone for your team. When you’re steady and optimistic, you create a culture where people feel safe to take risks and collaborate. They aren’t paralyzed by the fear of failure.
  1. Boosts Morale and Resilience: Teams take their cues from their leaders. If you model resilience and calm under pressure, they’ll be more likely to stay positive and push through challenges.
  1. Shows Emotional Intelligence: Leaders who embody a non-anxious presence are emotionally intelligent. They can regulate their emotions, stay composed, and create a ripple effect that helps others do the same.

How to Develop a Non-Anxious Presence

Being a non-anxious leader isn’t about pretending everything’s fine when it’s not. It’s about finding a way to stay grounded, no matter what’s happening around you. Here are a few ways to develop that presence:

  1. Check in with Yourself: Self-awareness is the first step. Take a moment to recognize your emotions. Are you feeling stressed, anxious, or frustrated? Knowing where you’re at helps you manage your emotions before they affect your team.
  1. Learn to Pause: When emotions are running high, hit pause. Take a deep breath, go for a quick walk, or do something to reset. This helps you avoid reacting out of emotion and gives you time to think clearly.
  1. Communicate with Intention: Your words and tone matter. Speak calmly, keep your body language open, and make sure your message is clear. This shows your team that you’re in control and focused on solutions.
  1. Focus on What You Can Control: Anxiety often comes from feeling like things are out of your hands. Instead of stressing over what you can’t change, focus on what you can—your actions, your communication, and how you respond to challenges.
  1. Model Calmness Under Pressure: Your team will follow your lead, especially when things get tough. If you stay calm and focused, they’ll be more likely to mirror that behavior.
  1. Empathy Without Feeding Anxiety: A non-anxious presence doesn’t mean ignoring your team’s emotions. It’s important to acknowledge how they’re feeling, show understanding, and provide reassurance. But instead of feeding into their anxiety, focus on what you can do to support and move forward.

Stay Calm, Cool, and Collected

As a leader, your emotions have a bigger impact than you might realize. Emotional contagion is real, but you can harness it for good by cultivating a non-anxious presence. When you stay calm and grounded, you create a ripple effect that influences your team’s mindset, performance, and overall morale.

In moments of uncertainty or high pressure, your team will look to you for guidance. If you can stay centered, manage your own emotional state, and lead with confidence, you’ll set the tone for your team to thrive—even when the going gets tough.

Written By Jon Plotner

Related Posts

green plants on soil

Two Types of Leaders: Which One Are You?

In all my years of coaching leaders — executives, pastors, ministry professionals, and marketplace leaders — I've noticed a pattern that never changes. It doesn't matter what industry you're in, what size your organization is, or how long you've been in leadership....

read more...
train, mountains, fields, rice fields, rice plantation, rice farm, rice paddies, railway, railroad, railway system, passenger train, transport, rural, countryside, landscape, nature

The System vs. Your Soul: How Senior Leaders Reframe Criticism

High-capacity, high-care leaders often risk tying their identity too closely to outcomes and other people’s reactions. When ownership increases, so does emotional exposure, causing feedback to land on your identity instead of just your role. This post shares a framework to build durable internal boundaries, allowing you to keep listening deeply without absorbing criticism as a personal verdict. The core practice is a crucial mental reframe: treating feedback as shared insight about the system we’re all in, not a critique of your worth. Learn how to set internal boundary rules, use cognitive defusion to create distance from sharp thoughts, and implement a repeatable process for transforming tough conversations into raw material for shared learning.

read more...
The Eye of the Storm: Why the Best Leaders are Carriers of the Calm

The Eye of the Storm: Why the Best Leaders are Carriers of the Calm

In navigating the complexities of leadership, one must recognize that the true essence of influence lies not just in decision-making but in the energy we radiate; the most impactful leaders harness a thoughtful stillness that invites connection and collaboration, ensuring their teams feel supported rather than strained, inspiring a collective resilience that transcends mere survival and fosters an environment where creativity flourishes and potential is fully realized, highlighting that the ultimate goal of leadership is not to command but to cultivate an atmosphere where every voice can rise, contributing to a symphony of shared success.

read more...
multi cultural people

Support & Leadership: Fostering Ownership and Partnership for Results

Yesterday, I attended a customer meeting with one of our customer success managers, and it turned into a real eye-opener about what leadership should be. My colleague shared on LinkedIn that instead of needing more oversight, Individual Contributors just want ownership and support. When leaders show up, they’re not just a title; they create trust and momentum. It’s key for leaders to champion decisions and support their teams without judgment. Leaders should empower rather than evaluate. The goal is to fuse the roles of leaders and ICs, promoting shared ownership and respect, so everyone wins together. It’s all about partnership, not hierarchy.

read more...
Patience in Bloom: Why Waiting Matters

Patience in Bloom: Why Waiting Matters

The story of a pink rhododendron that took six years to bloom serves as a metaphor for personal growth. Despite consistent care, it initially showed no visible signs of progress. This spring, it burst into beautiful blossoms, prompting reflections on life’s invisible growth periods. Just as the rhododendron established its roots before blooming, we too can spend long periods working hard without immediate results. This emphasizes that patience and continued effort are essential, as many projects and goals develop quietly beneath the surface. The waiting time is not wasted, and eventually, each person’s ‘moment of blooming’ will arrive.

read more...
man wearing black polo shirt and gray pants sitting on white chair

Responding to Feedback: Strategies for Effective Growth

Feedback can feel personal and challenging, often seeming like a direct attack on one’s identity. However, understanding that feedback reflects behavior and perception, rather than core identity, is crucial. Acknowledging that others’ perceptions can differ from intentions allows an opportunity for growth. It’s essential to approach feedback with humility and clarity, asking questions to bridge misunderstandings. While not all feedback may be entirely valid, each piece can reveal insights about your influence and relationships. Ultimately, how you respond to feedback can transform it from a threat to a valuable tool for personal and professional development.

read more...

0 Comments